BTEC EXTENDED DIPLOMA – CREATIVE MEDIA PRODUCTION (TV & Film )
Unit 26: Film Studies
Assignment 1 of 1
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre – ORIGINAL vs. REMAKE
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre is an American horror film, directed by Tobe Hooper. The film is based around five friends, who are visiting their grandpa's old house. Whilst their they are hunted down and terrorized by a chainsaw wielding killer, known as “Leatherface”, along with his family of grave-robbing cannibals. Texas Chainsaw Massacre, or TCM, was very controversial upon its release in 1974, and left audience’s “Disgusted, it was even banned in certain parts of the world, Including the UK at one point. But in modern day, TCM is regarded as a classic horror, and was a massive influence on many horror films to come.
|
The Hitch-Hiker from the original TCM |
TCM includes some very powerful scene’s, especially for the time when it was released. Including the Hitch-hiker scene, in which the five friends pick up a hitch-hiker (who we later find out is part of the crazy cannibal family) who talks about the slaughterhouse, takes a picture of franklin, who is one of the five friends, and then burns it in the back of the van And then cuts his own hand open with a blade which was concealed in his sock, and then proceeds to cut franklin. At this point he is thrown out of the van; as he smears his blood all of the side of it. This scene is extremely near the beginning of the movie, and really sets the mood for what is to come.
|
The very contreversial "Hook" Scene |
Another very powerful scene, is the scene where Leatherface has just killed the character of Kirk, and the character of Pam enters the house to look for him, and ends up falling into a room which is covered in bones and carcass’. There are some very good shots in this part as it just cuts from shot to shot, showing you the hundreds and hundreds of bones everywhere, and this is very powerful. After that Leatherface captures Pam and places her on a hook in his “Workshop”, at the time of its release this was a very disturbing scene for the public, and was one of the reasons it was considered so controversial.
And of course we cannot forget the infamous Dinner table scene, which show the character of Sally, tied to a chair, and the full sick, twisted cannibal family, this is an extremely powerful scene and the aftermath of this is the climatic chase scene.
In 2003, a remake of “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre” was released, under the same title, now although the story line is very similar, it is also different. The story is still based on five friends, who get hunted down by the now “Infamous” Leatherface. But the circumstances are very different, which we will get to in a minute. As an overall the feel and look of the movie are quite similar, although the re-make feels slightly darker, and it feels like there is more of a story-line to it. It includes more back-story and talks more about the now named “Hewitt family” than the original. As for the story itself, the five friends are driving through the backwoods of Texas, and pick up a traumatized hitchhiker, who shoots herself in their van. Shaken by the suicide, the group seeks help from the locals, but their situation becomes even more of a living nightmare when they knock on the door of a remote house. It's quickly realised that a family of inbred psychopaths reside there, and the friends suddenly find themselves running for their lives. Not far behind is chainsaw-wielding cannibal known as Leatherface. As you can see, the story is somewhat different, but still similar enough to realise that it is a remake. As for the story and individual scenes in detail, the TCM Remake is quite different, the Cannibalistic family now consists of roughly 7-8 members, which as drastically grown compared to the original 4.
Also many of the most powerful scenes of the original have had been changed quite drastically. For example, the hitch-hiker scene now consists of a girl, who is a victim of Leatherface. she shoots herself in the head back of the van at the beginning. In my opinion the changes made to this scene and the shots used (Especially the shot where we can see the characters through the gun-shot hole in the girls head) set a very different mood to the original. I can’t decide if this is for better or for worse, as both scenes are very well put together, and really set up the story very well in their own ways.
|
The lead up to the "Hook" scene in the Remake |
Another scene which is quite different is the hook scene, as this time it is the Character of Andy who is placed on the hook, but at the same time the scene is very similar, as it is still set in Leatherface’s “Workshop”, which is now in the basement. Also the dinner table scene in the original, which is personally my favourite scene. Is very different, as in the remake they aren’t really around the table; they are just in the kitchen/living room.
But once again the female lead is tied to a chair. Although this scene is extremely different to the original, it still shows the relationships between the members of the Hewitt family and the way they live, and even goes into deeper emotional levels than the original. And in my opinion the meaning of this scene (in the original and the remake) is to convey to the audience the relationships of the family. So even though the scene is done very differently I think it means exactly the same thing. There is also a big similarity between the two films, one of the most iconic shots of the original was included in the remake, this is the shot where Leatherface slams his steel door, which was one of the scariest and most memorable shots, in both the remake and the original.
In conclusion, I think that both the original and remake of TCM are great pieces of film, and even though the content of the remake is somewhat different, I think it sparks the same emotions, thoughts and feelings as the original. Which I think makes it one of the greatest remakes of all time, as it is basically just a modern version of the film, it can bring that same fear, and that same amazement, and same thrills to another generation.